Actor Andrew Shue and attorney Marilee Fiebig have publicly shared the first photograph from their recent New Jersey wedding, marking an official milestone in a relationship that began following their high-profile divorces from former television anchors Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes. In a joint Instagram post published on November 15, 2026, Shue, 59, and Fiebig, 49, debuted a black-and-white portrait from their ceremony, writing in the accompanying caption, "Somehow, some way, this story has a happy ending and now a beautiful new beginning," according to TMZ.
The newly released image shows Fiebig dressed in a white lace bridal gown while holding a floral bouquet, standing beside Shue, who wore a classic suit and tie for the occasion. The social media post offers the public its first direct visual confirmation of the private nuptials, which took place approximately two weeks prior in the Garden State.
Inside the New Jersey Estate Ceremony
While the couple kept the ceremony largely out of the public eye, multiple entertainment outlets have reported details regarding the setting and timing of the event.
According to Us Weekly, Shue and Fiebig exchanged vows at their 92-acre country estate located near Stockton, New Jersey. However, media reports differ slightly on the exact date of the nuptials and the characterization of the property. While TMZ reports that the couple got married on November 2, Page Six and other industry reports state the ceremony occurred on November 1 at the couple's New Jersey farm.
The autumn wedding followed a relatively private engagement period. TMZ notes that Shue and Fiebig got engaged in the spring of 2026, specifically in May, though the news did not become widely known to the public until October, just days before they walked down the aisle.
Speaking about their engagement in an October interview cited by Us Weekly, Shue expressed optimism about their shared future, stating, "We’re very grateful and hopeful," and adding at the time, "I don’t know how it happened, but there’s a happy ending."
From 2022 Broadcast Scandal to New Partnerships
The public fascination surrounding Shue and Fiebig's marriage is closely tied to the events of November 2022, when their former spouses, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, were photographed together in romantic settings outside of their duties as co-hosts of ABC's GMA3: What You Need to Know. At the time the photographs surfaced, Shue was legally married to Robach, whom he wed in 2010, and Fiebig was married to Holmes, also since 2010.
The resulting media scrutiny led ABC News to pull Robach and Holmes off the air on December 5, 2022, pending an internal review.
On January 27, 2023, ABC News President Kim Godwin released a formal statement confirming the anchors' permanent departure from the network, noting that after several conversations, "we all agreed it’s best for everyone that they move on from ABC News," as reported by Page Six.
While tabloid coverage initially framed the 2022 scandal as an extramarital affair, the timeline of the separations has been described differently by the parties involved. Both couples were reportedly in the process of separating when the photographs became public. During a 2023 episode of their iHeartRadio podcast, Amy and T.J., Holmes directly disputed the adultery narrative, stating, "To be clear, we were outed as being in a relationship, but everyone else thought we were being outed as adulterers — being outed as cheating on our spouses — and it wasn’t the case."
Following the network departures, the legal dissolutions of both marriages proceeded quickly.
Shue finalized his divorce from Robach in March 2023, while Fiebig settled her divorce from Holmes in October 2023. Two months later, in December 2023, reports first emerged that Shue and Fiebig had developed a romantic relationship of their own.
Parallel Marriages and Blended Families
Shue and Fiebig's November ceremony took place less than two months after their former spouses also wed. According to Us Weekly, Robach, 53, and Holmes, 49, became engaged in September 2025 and married in a private ceremony in Arkansas on September 19, 2026, a milestone confirmed by a local county clerk in October.
Both marriages involve extensive blended family dynamics. Fiebig and Holmes share a daughter, Sabine. Holmes also has two older children, daughter Brianna and son Jaiden, from his previous marriage to Amy Ferson from 2004 to 2007. Robach shares two daughters, Ava and Annalise, with her first husband, Tim McIntosh, to whom she was married from 1996 to 2008.
On their podcast, Robach and Holmes have previously discussed the process of acclimating their children to the restructured family units.
Holmes noted in a 2023 broadcast that he allowed his daughter Sabine to set the pace regarding her relationship with Robach, explaining that Sabine had known Robach since she was a toddler and had voluntarily chosen to spend time with them. Robach added that they had remained patient while navigating the children's feelings, describing the domestic environment as peaceful.
As Shue and Fiebig settle into married life in New Jersey, Robach and Holmes are reportedly exploring a joint return to broadcast television. Industry insiders told Page Six that the former ABC anchors are pitching themselves as a married co-hosting team in the mold of Live with Kelly and Mark, with Robach reportedly turning down individual hosting opportunities—including consideration for a role at Inside Edition—in order to secure a joint project with Holmes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will the couple confirm whether the ceremony took place on November 1 or November 2?
Neither Andrew Shue, Marilee Fiebig, nor their representatives have officially confirmed the exact date of the ceremony. Media outlets remain split, with TMZ reporting the wedding occurred on November 2, 2026, and Page Six reporting November 1, 2026.
Have specifics about the dress designer, guest list, or officiant been released?
No. Beyond the single black-and-white photograph showing Fiebig in a white lace gown and Shue in a suit and tie at their 92-acre property near Stockton, New Jersey, the couple has not disclosed the identities of their wedding planner, dress designer, photographer, officiant, or the number of guests in attendance.
How do Shue and Fiebig describe the beginning of their relationship?
The couple has maintained strict privacy regarding the exact timeline of their courtship, which became public in December 2023 after both of their divorces were finalized. In their only public comments on the romance, Shue told reporters in October 2026 that he did not know how it happened, and their joint November 15 Instagram post summarized the courtship simply as a story with "a happy ending and now a beautiful new beginning."
Sources
- TMZ - Andrew Shue & Marilee Fiebig Share First Look of Wedding Day: 'This Story Has a Happy Ending'
- Us Weekly - Andrew Shue Breaks Silence After Marilee Fiebig Wedding: ‘Beautiful New Beginning’
- Page Six - Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes want to be the next Kelly Ripa and Mark Consuelos as they plot TV comeback