A24’s Elizabeth Holmes documentary You Can See Everything claimed the top spot at the North American box office over the October 30 to November 1 Halloween weekend, narrowly outperforming DC Studios’ comic book adaptation Clayface. Directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, the non-fiction release climbed to number one in its third weekend of theatrical play as Clayface moved into its second frame. While initial Sunday projections showed the two titles separated by mere hundreds of thousands of dollars, Monday final tallies confirmed the nearly three-hour documentary secured a rare victory over a major studio genre release during one of the quietest theatrical weekends of the year.

A Tight Race From Sunday Estimates to Monday Finals

The battle for the weekend box office crown came down to the wire, with competing studios initially projecting a near-tie on Sunday before Monday actuals settled the contest. According to the Associated Press, Sunday studio estimates placed You Can See Everything in first place with $10.6 million from 2,655 locations, holding a razor-thin $200,684 lead over Clayface, which was estimated at $10.4 million. Meanwhile, Variety noted that Sunday projections had each distributor claiming the number one spot with estimates hovering around $10.5 million to $10.6 million as the documentary expanded to 3,242 venues against Clayface's 3,478 theaters.

Daily attendance shifts played a major role in how the weekend unfolded. According to Deadline, Clayface actually led the daily ticket sales on Halloween Saturday, earning $4.2 million compared to $3.58 million for You Can See Everything. However, the documentary posted a stronger recovery on Sunday to overtake the comic book movie. When final studio numbers were tallied on Monday, Variety reported that You Can See Everything finished with $11.4 million ($11.44 million according to Monday updates via Yahoo News), beating Clayface's final sophomore haul of $11 million.

The chronology of the matchup also highlighted differences in recent box office coverage. While an earlier report from The Signal focused on Clayface's prior opening weekend—when the DC film debuted at number one with $24.5 million against the documentary's $19.5 million second frame—the Halloween weekend marked a direct reversal of fortunes as the A24 documentary overtook the superhero horror title in their third and second weeks, respectively.

Why the Elizabeth Holmes Documentary Connected With Audiences

For a non-fiction film running more than three hours to ascend to the top of the domestic box office in its third week is nearly unprecedented in modern theatrical distribution. Paul Dergarabedian, head of marketplace trends at Rentrak, told Variety that the third-weekend climb is "a rare achievement for any film, let alone a documentary running more than three hours."

The film's premise centers on disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans, who invited a skeptical film crew into their home 34 days before she reported to federal prison to serve her sentence for fraud, according to The Signal. Driven by strong word-of-mouth and repeat viewings from moviegoers drawn to the stranger-than-fiction portrait, the project has become a major financial success for A24. Produced on a modest $7 million budget, You Can See Everything had accumulated an estimated $63.8 million to $63.9 million domestically by Sunday according to IndieWire and The Hollywood Reporter, before rising to $64.7 million in Monday actuals prior to any international rollout.

A Leaner Strategy for DC Studios and 'Clayface'

Despite slipping to second place in its sophomore outing, Clayface represents a calculated financial pivot for DC Studios. Directed by James Watkins and co-written by Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini, the R-rated body horror film stars Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen, a rising Hollywood actor disfigured by gangsters who undergoes an experimental nanotech treatment administered by a scientist played by Naomi Ackie. Keeping Batman entirely out of the narrative, the story operates as a standalone revenge thriller featuring supporting performances from Eddie Marsan and Max Minghella.

Rather than spending upward of $200 million on traditional tentpoles, DC kept costs contained for the lesser-known villain. While The Signal cited a reported $40 million budget needing roughly $100 million globally to break even, Variety placed the production cost at $44 million—a sharp contrast to DC's $225 million-budgeted Superman last year and July's $175 million Supergirl (which The Signal noted cost $170 million and grossed about $126 million worldwide). With Sunday estimates placing Clayface's domestic haul at $44.1 million and Monday actuals bringing it to $44.6 million in North America and $83 million globally, the film is on track to be a solid theatrical performer. Reception has also been generally positive, holding a 76% critics score and 93% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes alongside an A- CinemaScore.

How Halloween Impacted the Broader Box Office Landscape

The close race between an indie documentary and a mid-budget horror comic book movie occurred against the backdrop of a sluggish holiday frame. Without any major new wide releases hitting multiplexes, and with Halloween falling directly on Saturday, theater operators faced stiff competition from trick-or-treating and holiday parties.

Estimates of the overall market size fluctuated throughout the weekend. A Saturday update from Deadline projected all titles would generate a combined total above $63 million, whereas the Associated Press reported on Sunday that overall North American ticket sales might not surpass $56 million. By Monday, Variety cited Rentrak data showing Friday-to-Sunday revenues across all films reached roughly $60 million. While that figure marked one of the slowest weekends of 2026, it still improved upon the 2025 Halloween weekend, which generated $49 million behind Regretting You and Black Phone 2.

Elsewhere on the charts, horror and seasonal holdovers continued to draw audiences. Rob Savage's horror film Other Mommy, starring Jessica Chastain and based on Josh Malerman's novel Incidents Around the House, added $2.5 million from 2,329 locations in its latest frame to cross the $100 million milestone against a $19 million budget, despite a 19% Rotten Tomatoes score, according to Collider. Meanwhile, Laika's stop-motion fantasy Wildwood held the number three spot on the domestic chart.

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the final studio-reported grosses and theater counts after Monday revisions?

Following Monday's final studio tallies, You Can See Everything finished in first place with $11.4 million (reported as $11.44 million by Deadline) across 3,242 venues, raising its domestic cumulative total to $64.7 million. Clayface finished second with $11 million from 3,478 theaters, bringing its North American total to $44.6 million and its global haul to $83 million.

How much did Halloween Saturday attendance patterns and Sunday recovery affect the close ranking?

Halloween falling on Saturday significantly suppressed evening moviegoing. Clayface actually won Halloween Saturday with $4.2 million compared to the documentary's $3.58 million. However, adult audiences turned out in stronger numbers on Sunday for You Can See Everything, allowing the documentary to erase Saturday's deficit and secure the overall weekend win.

Why did some reports mention a $24.5 million debut for 'Clayface'?

The $24.5 million figure refers to Clayface's opening weekend gross from the prior frame, when it debuted at number one ahead of You Can See Everything's $19.5 million second weekend. During the October 30 to November 1 Halloween frame, Clayface was in its second weekend and You Can See Everything was in its third.

Sources